Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Week 6: Chapter 8 Discussion

In Chapter 8, I found, "General Claims and Their Contradictories" interesting because it's important to identify a valid claim.  These claims typically carry true premises but leads to a inaccurate conclusion.  A good example that the book used was, "Some dogs like cats.  Some cats like dogs.  So some dogs and cats like each other."  This is not a valid argument because it's more of a belief.  Then the book goes into teaching us the difference between "all" and "some."  With all meaning, every single one with no exception.  Some meaning, at least one but not all.
After understanding general claims, it made me realized that I do make general claims and it's a bad habit.  I would say things like, all cats give me allergies or some dogs are scary.  Then the book goes into contradictories of these claims.
Claim:  Some dogs are scary.
Contradictory:  No dogs are scary.
Claim:  All cats give me allergies.
Contradictory:  Some cats don't give me allergies.
Hence, I've learned to use more critical thinking on a daily basis to make valid arguments so people cannot contradict me.  It's gratifying when I'm able to make articulate claim that's reasonable.

2 comments:

  1. I believe you did a great job picking this subject to talk about. I agree that "General Claims and thier Contradictories" was a good subject to discuss. You did a good job by using an example from the book. Sometimes using an example from the book is better than using one from your own knowlegde is more effective. I agree with your statement that you make general claims because I have a bad habit of doing that too. I believe the reader will have a good understanding of General claims after reading your exclaimation. Overall you did a great job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This was my second choice when it came to choosing a subject to make a post. This idea really caught my eye in the reading and you just broadened my view of it. General claims and there contradictories was a good topic to discuss in your post and you did a particularly good job of it. Starting with your defining at the beginning all the way to your example was solid. It was very easy to comprehend and if I had not known of this topic then I would feel very enlightened. Great work on this post keep up the good work my fellow group member.

    ReplyDelete